Skip to main content

Transparency Portals - An invitation to Identity theft

Pleased as punch
So, you read with glee the number of cylinders your minister was using. He should not be using so many subsidised cylinders? Fine

Guess what? Your name, address and number of cylinders and when you ordered them is there too.

Privacy Disaster
This portal is a disaster from a privacy perspective. The idea was very poorly thought through. Imagine an e-commerce company just dumping customer data on the web, amillion people would be baying for blood.

One of the Gas companies has embedded dealer ids in the URL query string itself. which allows for ralatively easy automated scraping. I could do a data scrape on ALLcustomers all over INDIA and filter for customers who use a certain number of cylinders. A perfect database to to do direct marketing.

Not scared yet?

Identity Theft

It is an even more perfect database to commit identity theft. All your basic identity/citizenship documents are predicated on your gas connection. Authentication to your bank. Gas bills are one of the easiest things to duplicate. Infact, you could get the details of the bill from the website itself.

It is just begging to be abused.

The government should instruct the gas marketing companies to take it down immediately and rethink the way they want to do this.

What Next?

Electricty bills? Since that is also subsidised. All Income tax payers? with PAN?

It's about time that the Government hire a CIO. These half assed e-governance initiatives are bound to trip up sooner than later.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Social Networking for Grown-Ups...

So much is said about social networks and how catch all social networks are all the rage right now. But look back a few years and you see all a landscape littered with yesterday's stars.
Friendster
Hi5
and to some extent
Orkut (Some may argue that Orkut is alive and kicking in India, but I beg to differ. Orkut isn't hip any mre, which means that over time it will slide into nothingness. After all which woman, wants 100 friend requests from absolute strangers)

And not to mention that the hundreds of new social networks that pop up every other day. Clearly a gold rush is on. The acquisition of Desimartini by HT 's Firefly eVenture is a symptom of this gold rush.
With the reported difficulties of Google & MS to monetise their respective ad properties of MySpace and Facebook, it is clear that we have seen all the hypergrowth we had to see, It will grow, there are after all several billion people on this planet but not necessarily to the point, where it will justify …

Wikipedia and News

As the 63rd Republic Day celebrations wound down. I happened to be on the Wikipedia page on the topic (Wikipedia Republic Day (India)) and started fixing some presentation issues regarding the references used.

I noticed something. News articles seem to have been sourced from Wikipedia. No big deal, blame it on a lazy journalist etc.

Here is where it started getting stranger. The wikipedia article started referencing the story that was sourced from wikipedia. In effect it was self referencing itself.

In this particular case, it was the list of Chief Guests at the Republic day parade. The older reference were links to MEA etc. which progressively started changing into references to news stories done in the recent past.

So, is wikipedia shaping the way we are being fed news? Sure, that is clearly the case.
Further, is wikipedia reinforcing the biases and errors that may have been crept in (as is expected in a crowdsourced article)?